LEE ROOD is projects and investigations editor at The Des Moines Register. A graduate of the University of Nebraska-Lincoln, Rood has spearheaded numerous reporting projects and investigations by the Register staff, including nationally award-winning pieces on biofuels, climate change,and abuse of power within a public job-training agency. Her own reporting over her 13 years with the newspaper has led to several changes in state and federal law, criminal charges against some of the targets of her investigations, and earned more than three dozen state and national awards. E-mail: email@example.com. Cell: 515-778-6670. Work: 515-284-8549.
Des Moines Register, Sept. 12, 2010
Tucson, Ariz. — Two fences – one concrete to block cars, the other barbed wire to block people – cut through a wide valley in the Tohono O’odham Nation Reservation west of Tucson.
Ground sensors and infrared night-vision cameras scan the vast terrain. Teams of Border Patrol agents comb dirt and concrete roads, perch at roadside checkpoints and search the Sonoran Desert by air and ATV.
Welcome to the nation’s busiest border and epicenter of the U.S. immigration debate. In April, Arizona adopted Senate Bill 1070, a polarizing state law that attempted to give state authorities more authority to crack down on illegal immigration. This spring and summer, as an angry electorate clamored for more immigration enforcement, Congress and President Barack Obama committed more federal resources than ever to border security.
What’s happened here since: a sharp drop in apprehensions of people attempting to cross the border, an economic hit because of fewer legal Mexican visitors, and declines in school enrollment.
Des Moines Register, Sept. 12, 2010
If you lived hundreds of miles away and listened only to the sound bites leading to passage of Senate Bill 1070, it would be easy to imagine some parts of Arizona as every bit as lawless as fabled Tombstone, circa 1881… But with some 800 federal agents now working in the city of 20,000, crimes affecting local residents are few and far between.
Des Moines Register, Sept. 13, 2010
Salt Lake City — … In Utah, an embarrassing crisis caused some leaders to take a detour from the rush toward a hard-line, restrictionist route. In the works is a pilot program that would balance greater enforcement with business needs and a legal avenue for undocumented immigrants already in the state to keep working.Proponents say they will complete a draft of their plan as soon as this week. They believe it could be a temporary solution some states are looking for as the country awaits the reform missing from Congress.
Des Moines Register, October 3, 2010
House Minority Leader Kraig Paulsen tried to pass legislation this year that would deny more state services to illegal immigrants.
Story Behind The Story
I wish all journalism conferences could be like the one held in Oklahoma for the IJJ fellows. I walked away with so much: dozens of new resources and sources, the advice of some excellent reporters who had written much more about immigration than me, and on-the-scene reporting one of a places where immigration had taken center stage.
Coming into the fellowship, I had just completed a series of stories about the effects of widespread arrests by a new ICE fugitive unit in Iowa. I could sense as I was reporting the climate in our state had changed, becoming a little more hard-line regarding illegal immigration than the “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” approach once embraced by so many in this meatpacking-agriculture state. I knew many Iowans were also at a crossroads in regard to how they would perceive any new state proposals likely to in the absence of federal immigration reform,.
The project I eventually completed attempted to frame the debate anticipated during the election season, based on facts rather than all the hyperbole. During the summer, I reported on the effects of the more hard-line approach on immigration that Oklahomans decided to take. After the fellowship, I did a lot of research about the different approaches being taken in different states to immigration issues. Dan Kowalski’s Bender’s Immigration Report, just one of the many resources I learned about, proved invaluable at this stage.
In the fall, I wrote about facts and myths surrounding the migration of immigrants, business and crime in the aftermath of the passage of Arizona’s toughest-in-the-nation legislation. After that, I examined an emerging proposal in Utah, where acrimony had yielded to a more even-handed approach to the state’s immigration issues.
Then I wrote about Iowa candidates’ views on immigration, poll results showing Iowans’ changing views and the state’s unique situation with regards to the immigration debate. One clear fact that people on both sides cannot escape: Illegal immigration may be one of the only things helping the state’s struggling economy to grow, according to several experts.
The stories — which included compelling video from both Utah and Arizona — shaped perfectly the immigration debate leading up to this fall’s gubernatorial election.
Our new governor (who is actually a former governor) and Republican-dominated Legislature championed a more hard-line stance on immigration during the campaign like many politicians across the country. But I’m told it’s highly unlikely any hard-line approach will pass this year at the Legislature. My stories made the facts clear before much of the debate and rhetoric began in earnest, which is critical to any thoughtful debate. They also acted as a starting point for Iowans to respond, which has happened mostly on our editorial pages.
I would not have been able to do these stories without the fellowship. My newspaper, like many others these days, is limiting dramatically its travel budget. The ability to use the fellowship money to travel help me witness and learn about the climate in other states, and the sources I gained during the fellowship proved invaluable.
Tips to other reporters:
° Try to find a unique angle to tell you story. So many stories were being written about immigration at the time I wrote my pieces that I knew I had to approach them from a compelling place. One was a Native American reservation on the Arizona border, where record numbers of border-crossers had been dying due to increased enforcement.
° With this or any other highly controversial issue, check your personal views at the door. Readers recognize bias, and fairness and context is imperative right now.
° Recognize when there is momentum to tell a certain kind of story and when there isn’t. During the campaign, there were reporters here who wanted to write features about struggling immigrants, as if to win over their readers.
I believe you have to learn where a majority of your readers stand on the issues, and respect that. A lot of perspectives are critical before a big policy change is made.